The Playwrights Forum Home 
 

SEARCH STAGEPLAYS.COM
THE WORLD'S LARGEST PLAY DATABASE

  STAGEPLAYS BOOKSHOP NEW CYBERPRESS PLAYS PLAYWRIGHTING BOOKS PUBLISH MY PLAY AFFILIATE PROGRAM THE THEATRE BANNER EXCHANGE  
The Playwrights Forum > The Art & Craft of Writing > Poet's Corner : Critique my Poem > The Magdalen Woman

* STAGEPLAYS WANTS TO PUBLISH YOUR PLAY *
click here for details

 Moderated by: Paddy, Edd
New Topic Reply Printer Friendly
The Magdalen Woman  Rate Topic 
AuthorPost
 Posted: Wed Nov 18th, 2009 01:23 am
  PM Quote Reply
1st Post
in media res
Moderator
 

Joined: Sun Jul 2nd, 2006
Location:  
Posts: 1925
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
I hope Paul leaves this thread as a lesson in the Forum's acceptance of anyone's criticism no matter how unschooled, discourteous and unprofessional which - in my opinion - it is. I have read other things by erlysman that were not written in this manner.

(However, if criticism is severe and personal, that is another story, and as in the past has been removed.)

I sent my critique of this poem to potabasil in a PM, and she responded professionally and courteously, which she and most of us on the Forum is our habit to do.

Potabasil, at least in my eyes, has advanced in this Forum more than anyone I have witnessed in three years here in her poetry. It has been truly a delight and more than wonderful to watch her growth and experimentation.

We all have enjoyed the stumblings of creativity each of us have gone through openly on this Forum. Anyone who is a regular on this Forum knows what I am talking about. And for those who are new members or guests, learn from this. We all have helped each other enormously and are willing to help anyone.

Potabasil's level-headed responding comment in the face of severe criticism from erlysman (and I make no judgment upon him/her personally; just how erlysman's comments were phrased) is an example of what can be/has been learned by not only potabasil but many of us on this most wonderful Forum. We gain guts and confidence in our work and submit it on an open Forum for critique....not condemnation.

I suggest erlysman rent "The Magdelene Sister" from Netflix.

Coming from the Roman Catholic Diocese that had the highest percentage of pedophile/sexually abusive priests in the United States - not number: Boston had that by sheer size, but percentile - and knowing most of them as I was an altar boy in the Cathedral parish (unmolested) I can tell you potabasil hit the nail on the head.

erlysman, your opinion is registered But there is a courteous way to register it and a discourteous way to register it. I hope it will be left on the Forum as an example of what not to do.

timmy, I think this is the first time I have ever seen you use a vulgarity on this Forum. Do you talk that way when you miss a four foot birdie putt?! Must I cover my eyes?! Makes me want to take up golf again and drive up to Minnesota to play a round!

edd: keep posting. Poets are born to arm wrestle with the Philistines!

best,

in media res

P. S. "Washboard as easel" seems painfully, excruciatingly perfect.

Last edited on Wed Nov 18th, 2009 04:37 am by in media res

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Tue Nov 17th, 2009 10:03 pm
  PM Quote Reply
2nd Post
timmy
Member
 

Joined: Fri Jun 9th, 2006
Location: Oz, Minnesota USA
Posts: 1079
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Your comments are rude, inflammatory, and uncalled for. Constructive criticism is most wanted and welcome here.

Yours is shit.

You're lucky the author is a gentle woman or she'd find you, pull your nose out, and tie it in a knot.

At best we can all only hope you recover from your recent bout with brain constipation.

timmy

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Tue Nov 17th, 2009 08:28 pm
  PM Quote Reply
3rd Post
Potabasil
Member


Joined: Thu Jan 24th, 2008
Location: Peyton Place, New Hampshire USA
Posts: 677
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Erslman

Thank you so much for taking the time to read my little poem.  I think I shall leave it as it is.

Potabasil

Last edited on Wed Nov 18th, 2009 12:05 am by Potabasil

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Tue Nov 17th, 2009 07:45 pm
  PM Quote Reply
4th Post
Edd
Moderator


Joined: Sat Jun 10th, 2006
Location: Denver, Colorado USA
Posts: 1622
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Wow, erslyman, I think I posted my last poem a couple months ago and now I think it will remain my last poem posted here. It's not like I plan to publish any of my offerings -- they're just my spirit expressing itself. I think I shall forget about poetry and take up painting in times of spiritual inspiration.

~edd

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Tue Nov 17th, 2009 01:02 pm
  PM Quote Reply
5th Post
Kurt
Member


Joined: Fri Sep 25th, 2009
Location: USA
Posts: 58
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 



Last edited on Sat Dec 12th, 2009 01:29 pm by Kurt

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Tue Nov 17th, 2009 12:14 pm
  PM Quote Reply
6th Post
erslyman
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Ineffective language. Washboard as easel seems comical. Though this falls flat for me. Somewhat confusing, disjointed your switch from objective "use the washboard" to "as her easel". Shouldn't it be 'your' easel.

Also in general, too much telling here. Show don't tell. Fallen and penitent. Would like to see how she is penitent.

One wishes for more specificity in such a work. More insight. The engagement is at a low ebb. Reduced to mere commentary.

Plain writing such as this is met with lukewarm response. Amateurish & pale.



 

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Sun Nov 15th, 2009 02:51 am
  PM Quote Reply
7th Post
Potabasil
Member


Joined: Thu Jan 24th, 2008
Location: Peyton Place, New Hampshire USA
Posts: 677
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 

Oh God I love apples my favourite fruit

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Sun Nov 15th, 2009 02:41 am
  PM Quote Reply
8th Post
timmy
Member
 

Joined: Fri Jun 9th, 2006
Location: Oz, Minnesota USA
Posts: 1079
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
At least I didn't offer you an apple ;)

timmy

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Sat Nov 14th, 2009 09:58 pm
  PM Quote Reply
9th Post
Edd
Moderator


Joined: Sat Jun 10th, 2006
Location: Denver, Colorado USA
Posts: 1622
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Perfect!

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Sat Nov 14th, 2009 09:55 pm
  PM Quote Reply
10th Post
Potabasil
Member


Joined: Thu Jan 24th, 2008
Location: Peyton Place, New Hampshire USA
Posts: 677
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Timmy

Thank you

Stop tempting me or I'll end up in the Magdalen laundry meself (LOL)

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Sat Nov 14th, 2009 09:18 pm
  PM Quote Reply
11th Post
timmy
Member
 

Joined: Fri Jun 9th, 2006
Location: Oz, Minnesota USA
Posts: 1079
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Potabasil:

Bravo!! (clap, clap, clap...applause)

Would be tempted to drop the last line and make it your title.

Would also be tempted to change "your" to "her"

timmy

Last edited on Sat Nov 14th, 2009 09:19 pm by timmy

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Fri Nov 13th, 2009 10:29 pm
  PM Quote Reply
12th Post
Potabasil
Member


Joined: Thu Jan 24th, 2008
Location: Peyton Place, New Hampshire USA
Posts: 677
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
Kurt

Thank you for your critiquing really appreciate it

Potabasil

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

 Posted: Fri Nov 13th, 2009 09:27 pm
  PM Quote Reply
13th Post
Kurt
Member


Joined: Fri Sep 25th, 2009
Location: USA
Posts: 58
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 
 

 

Last edited on Sat Dec 12th, 2009 01:29 pm by Kurt

Back To Top PM Quote Reply  

 Posted: Fri Nov 13th, 2009 08:23 pm
  PM Quote Reply
14th Post
Potabasil
Member


Joined: Thu Jan 24th, 2008
Location: Peyton Place, New Hampshire USA
Posts: 677
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 



Fallen fallen
penitent woman
use the washing board
as her easel

Paint the picture
for the people
show them inside

The Magdalen laundry





Last edited on Sat Nov 14th, 2009 09:53 pm by Potabasil

Back To Top PM Quote Reply

Current time is 11:58 am  
The Playwrights Forum > The Art & Craft of Writing > Poet's Corner : Critique my Poem > The Magdalen Woman Top




UltraBB 1.17 Copyright © 2007-2011 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.1665 seconds (15% database + 85% PHP). 28 queries executed.